TL;DR
Print It My Way and Kickflip both sit in the "let customers customize products before checkout" category, but they target different stores:
- Kickflip wins for true 3D configurators. Build-your-own bicycles, modular furniture, custom skateboards, configurable electronics — products with multiple physical components that customers assemble in 3D before buying. Kickflip's 3D engine is genuinely the standout capability and worth the transaction fee for stores in this category.
- Print It My Way wins on flat pricing and 2D personalization. $9.99/mo at the lowest paid tier with no transaction fee, vs Kickflip's "starts at 1.95% on customized products sold and decreases with volume, down to 0%" (Kickflip's developer response, Shopify App Store). For text-on-mug, name-on-shirt, photo-on-canvas, monogram-on-jewelry, you're paying a percentage of every custom sale forever — even at low volumes.
Pick Kickflip if your products are multi-component configurations that genuinely benefit from 3D assembly. Pick Print It My Way if your products are flat-image personalizable — you'll pay a flat $9.99–$39.99/mo and keep the percentage of every custom order that would have gone to Kickflip's transaction fee.
At-a-glance comparison
| Feature | Print It My Way | Kickflip |
|---|---|---|
| Free plan (no expiry) | ✓ | — |
| Pricing model | Flat monthly | Subscription + transaction fee* |
| Starter price | $9.99/mo | Subscription + 1.95%* |
| Mid tier price | $19.99/mo | Subscription + 1.95% (volume-tiered)* |
| Top tier price | $39.99/mo | Custom (enterprise)* |
| Per-item transaction fee | $0 (none) | 1.95% → 0% by volume* |
| 2D canvas live preview | ✓ | ✓ |
| 3D product configurator | — | ✓ (core feature) |
| Multi-component assembly | — | ✓ |
| Custom fonts | 35+ Google Fonts | Configurable |
| Logo / image upload | ✓ (Pro+) | ✓ |
| Conditional logic | ✓ (Pro+) | ✓ |
| Custom option sets / fields | ✓ (10 field types) | Configurator-driven |
| Cart Transform–native fees | ✓ | Varies |
| Multi-platform (BigCommerce, custom) | Shopify only | ✓ |
| Best for | 2D-personalizable products | Multi-component 3D configurations |
* Kickflip's transaction-fee structure is quoted from the developer's official response on the Kickflip Shopify App Store listing: "Our transaction fee starts at 1.95% on customized products sold and decreases with volume, down to 0%." Subscription pricing varies by plan; verify on the Kickflip Shopify App Store listing before deciding.
Pricing — what you actually pay
This is the comparison Kickflip's marketing pages skip over. The 1.95% transaction fee scales linearly with your custom-product revenue; Print It My Way's flat fee doesn't. Here's the year-one math at four store sizes:
Break-even calculation
Print It My Way Basic is $9.99/mo. Kickflip's 1.95% transaction fee equals that $9.99 at $512/month in custom product sales. Above that volume, every additional dollar in custom sales is pure savings on Print It My Way — and that's only counting the transaction fee, not Kickflip's subscription on top.
Year-one cost at four store sizes
Assuming all customized-product revenue runs through the personalizer:
| Custom sales / month | Kickflip transaction fee* | Print It My Way (flat) | Annual gap |
|---|---|---|---|
| $2,500 | $48.75/mo | $9.99/mo (Basic) | ~$465/yr |
| $5,000 | $97.50/mo | $9.99/mo (Basic) | ~$1,050/yr |
| $25,000 | $487.50/mo | $19.99/mo (Pro) | ~$5,610/yr |
| $100,000 | $1,950/mo | $39.99/mo (Advanced) | ~$22,920/yr |
* Kickflip's transaction fee "decreases with volume, down to 0%" per the vendor — these figures use the entry 1.95% rate and don't include Kickflip's monthly subscription, which is on top. The exact volume tiers aren't published. Use these numbers as upper bounds and confirm your specific tier with Kickflip directly.
When Kickflip's per-transaction model is justified
If your customizer drives a small fraction of your overall revenue and the 3D capability genuinely lifts conversion on multi-component products, Kickflip can pay for itself even at high custom volumes. Their homepage claims "Kickflip merchants have driven $100M+ in custom product sales, converting 150% more customers and achieving up to 50% higher profit margins" (gokickflip.com) — directional vendor numbers, not audited, but consistent with the value 3D configurators add for the right product category.
The structural problem with % fees on personalized products: they tax success. The more your custom products sell, the more you pay — not just for capability, but for revenue you generated. A flat fee like Print It My Way's puts that growth in your pocket.
Pricing is the most likely thing to be out of date in this comparison. Cross-check both apps' current rates before deciding.
Feature-by-feature deep dive
Live preview canvas (2D)
Both apps render a real-time preview as the customer enters text or uploads a logo. Print It My Way's 2D canvas is the entire product surface; Kickflip's 2D canvas exists but is the entry-level layer beneath its 3D configurator.
- Print It My Way edge: simpler editor, faster setup, lighter front-end footprint. Stores ship their first personalizer in under 10 minutes.
- Kickflip edge: the canvas integrates with the 3D viewer when you need to expand into multi-component configurations later.
3D configurator and multi-component assembly
This is Kickflip's defining feature and the reason its transaction-fee pricing exists. The 3D configurator lets customers assemble products from multiple components — frames, wheels, panels, materials, finishes — and rotate the assembled product before buying.
- Print It My Way: no 3D, no multi-component assembly. We're a 2D-canvas personalizer.
- Kickflip: 3D + assembly are the standout capability. If you sell custom bicycles, modular furniture, configurable footwear, build-your-own electronics, or any product with physically distinct components that customers select and combine, this is what you're paying for.
Verdict: Kickflip wins definitively here. If multi-component 3D configuration is core to your store, the rest of this comparison is mostly academic — you need a configurator, not a personalizer.
Custom options beyond Shopify variants
Personalization (text, photos, logos) and custom options (size matrix beyond Shopify's variants, color swatches, gift-wrap upcharges, conditional fields) are different things. Most stores need both.
- Print It My Way: 10 distinct field types — radio, checkbox, checkbox group, dropdown (single/multi), color swatch, image swatch, text area, switch, switch group — with per-choice pricing and conditional logic. Bundled in the same app, same price.
- Kickflip: options exist within the configurator framework. Excellent for component selection in a multi-part product; less natural for "add gift wrap for $5" or "rush production for $10" upcharges that don't belong on a 3D model.
Verdict: Print It My Way handles flat add-on options more cleanly. Kickflip handles part-selection options more cleanly. Match the tool to the option type.
Charging for personalization
- Print It My Way: native Shopify Cart Transform API. Personalization fees merge into the product line item via lineExpand. No fee products visible in the cart, no separate cart line for the personalization upcharge.
- Kickflip: own pricing engine; upcharges are configured per-component in the 3D model. The 1.95% transaction fee is on top — it's a vendor fee, not a customer-visible upcharge.
Verdict: Print It My Way's approach is cleaner for the customer experience and doesn't add a recurring vendor tax on every custom sale. Kickflip's per-component pricing is more flexible inside complex configurations.
Setup complexity
- Print It My Way: ~5 minutes from install to first live personalizer on a product. No 3D models to prepare, no component rules to define.
- Kickflip: a basic 2D configuration is quick. A real multi-component 3D product (the use case Kickflip is built for) requires uploading and texturing 3D model assets, defining assembly rules, and configuring how parts snap together — typically days of work for non-trivial products.
Verdict: If you don't need 3D assembly, Kickflip's setup overhead is dead weight. If you do, that overhead buys real capability.
Multi-platform support
- Print It My Way: Shopify only.
- Kickflip: Shopify, BigCommerce, and custom integrations.
Verdict: If you operate stores across platforms and want one configurator everywhere, Kickflip wins. If you're Shopify-only, Print It My Way wins on Shopify-native depth and flat pricing.
Order management
Both: customization details appear on the Shopify order. Print It My Way has a dedicated orders dashboard inside the app showing per-line-item personalization breakdown (text entries, fonts, colors, uploaded logos). Kickflip attaches configurator data — selected components, materials, dimensions — to the order; production teams use this to fulfill the configured product.
Best for whom?
You should pick Kickflip if:
- You sell multi-component configurable products (bikes, modular furniture, custom skateboards, configurable electronics, build-your-own kits) where customers genuinely need to assemble parts in 3D before buying.
- The 3D viewer measurably lifts conversion on your store and a percentage of that revenue is a fair price to pay for it.
- You operate Shopify + BigCommerce + a custom storefront and want one configurator everywhere.
- Your custom-product revenue is small enough that the 1.95% transaction fee won't compound into thousands per month.
You should pick Print It My Way if:
- Your products are flat-image personalizable (apparel, drinkware, gifts, signage, awards, accessories, jewelry, phone cases) — 2D is enough.
- You're growing custom-product revenue and don't want a vendor taking a percentage of every sale.
- You need both a personalizer AND a custom-options builder in one app at one price (engraving fonts + gift-wrap upcharge + rush shipping all on the same product).
- You want a real free plan that doesn't expire.
- You want add-on fees to land cleanly in the cart via Cart Transform.
If you're undecided: install Print It My Way's free plan and build one personalizer. If you can express your product as a 2D canvas with text, logo, photo, and a few option fields, you've found your app — for $0/month, no transaction fee.
Honest pros & cons
Print It My Way
Pros:
- Free plan with no expiry, no transaction fees
- Flat monthly pricing — your bill doesn't grow with your custom sales
- Native Cart Transform fee handling — cleanest cart experience
- Bundled personalizer + 10-field option-set builder
- Three out-of-the-box layouts (popup / drawer / fullscreen)
- Fast 5-minute setup
Cons:
- No 3D configurator or multi-component assembly — disqualifying for build-your-own products
- No POD integrations baked in
- Shopify only — no multi-platform
- Newer app — fewer reviews / case studies than Kickflip
Kickflip
Pros:
- Best-in-class 3D product configurator for multi-component products
- Multi-platform (Shopify, BigCommerce, custom)
- Volume discount on the transaction fee — drops toward 0% at scale (per Kickflip's vendor statement)
- Strong vendor-reported track record ("$100M+ in custom product sales", per gokickflip.com)
Cons:
- 1.95% per-item transaction fee at the entry tier — taxes every customized sale
- No real free plan equivalent
- Setup is heavy for stores that don't need 3D assembly
- 3D requires you to maintain 3D model assets — non-trivial
- Volume tier breakpoints aren't publicly disclosed — you negotiate directly
Setup & UX
- Time to first live customizer: Print It My Way ships in ~5 minutes for a 2D product. Kickflip ships a basic flow quickly, but a real 3D configuration requires model preparation that often takes days.
- Theme integration: Both use Shopify app blocks; no liquid editing required. Verify your theme is on Online Store 2.0 first.
- Learning curve: Print It My Way's editor has fewer concepts to master. Kickflip rewards investment with deeper 3D capability you can't replicate elsewhere — but only if you actually need it.
Customer support & track record
- Kickflip: longer track record, sales-led model with onboarding included for 3D configurations, established team.
- Print It My Way: newer app. Direct support at support@printitmyway.com; priority queue on the Advanced plan ($39.99/mo). Response typically within 24 hours; Advanced gets priority.
If you need hands-on onboarding for a 3D configuration, Kickflip is the safer pick. If you'd rather have direct, fast email support from a small team and a self-serve flat-fee app, Print It My Way often wins on responsiveness and predictability.
Frequently asked questions
What is Kickflip's transaction fee?
Per Kickflip's developer response on the Shopify App Store: "Our transaction fee starts at 1.95% on customized products sold and decreases with volume, down to 0%." The fee applies to the value of the customized item itself — not to your full order — and is on top of Kickflip's monthly subscription. Print It My Way charges no transaction fee at any tier.
At what monthly sales does Print It My Way become cheaper than Kickflip's transaction fee alone?
Print It My Way Basic ($9.99/mo) covers Kickflip's 1.95% fee on roughly $512 of customized products per month. Above that, every additional dollar in custom sales is pure savings. At $5,000/mo in custom orders the gap is ~$87/mo; at $25,000/mo it's ~$478/mo; at $100,000/mo, before Kickflip's volume discount kicks in, it approaches $1,950/mo.
Does Print It My Way support 3D product configuration?
No. Print It My Way is a 2D-canvas personalizer for text, fonts, logos, and photos on a flat product image. If you sell true multi-component configurable products (custom bikes, modular furniture, build-your-own electronics) where customers need to rotate and assemble parts, Kickflip's 3D configurator is the right tool.
Does Kickflip support simple text-on-product personalization?
Kickflip can do text personalization, but its setup model and pricing are built around configurable products. For pure text-on-mug, name-on-shirt, or monogram-on-jewelry use cases you're paying configurator pricing — and a transaction fee — for capabilities you won't use.
Does Kickflip have a free plan?
Kickflip's pricing is subscription plus the per-item transaction fee; there is no free plan equivalent to Print It My Way's. Print It My Way's free plan covers 1 personalizer, 1 option set, and 10 product assignments indefinitely with no transaction fees.
Can I migrate from Kickflip to Print It My Way?
There is no automatic import. Plan to recreate your personalizers in Print It My Way (typically 5–15 minutes per simple product; longer for products that were heavily configured in Kickflip's 3D model). Kickflip-era orders keep their original line item data on the Shopify order; only future orders use the new app.
Which is faster to set up?
Print It My Way ships a live personalizer in roughly 5 minutes for a 2D product. Kickflip's setup is faster for a basic flow but materially heavier for products that require 3D model preparation — uploading, configuring assembly rules, and texturing parts can be days of work for non-trivial products.
What does Kickflip's homepage claim about merchant results?
Kickflip's homepage states: "Kickflip merchants have driven $100M+ in custom product sales, converting 150% more customers and achieving up to 50% higher profit margins." These are aggregate vendor-reported numbers, not third-party-audited; treat them as directional. The 1.95%-and-down transaction fee is the verifiable cost figure to plan against.
Verdict
If you sell multi-component configurable products where customers genuinely need to assemble parts in 3D, install Kickflip — its configurator is the differentiator. If your products are flat-image personalizable, install Print It My Way for free. You'll get a 2D canvas, an option-set builder, no transaction fee, and a flat monthly bill that doesn't grow as your custom sales grow.
Install Print It My Way — Free See all personalizer alternatives