TL;DR — pick by use case
- Print It My Way ($9.99–$39.99/mo flat, no transaction fees, real free plan) — best for 2D visual personalization on apparel, drinkware, jewelry, gifts, signs, photo products. Cart Transform pricing native.
- Customily ($49/mo + tiered per-item fees per customily.com/pricing) — best for stores with deep Printful/Printify/Gelato POD workflows and mature print-file generation requirements.
- Zakeke ($29.99/mo + 1.7–1.9% per item with $0.02 floor and $15 cap per zakeke.zendesk.com) — best for 3D-configurable products (eyewear, furniture, jewelry) and AR preview.
The pricing models matter more than the sticker prices. A growing custom-product store on Print It My Way's $39.99 Advanced tier pays $479.88/year regardless of volume. The same store on Zakeke or Customily pays subscription plus transaction fees that grow with revenue — the gap can be thousands of dollars per year at scale.
Full feature & pricing matrix
| Feature | Print It My Way | Customily | Zakeke |
|---|---|---|---|
| Pricing model | Flat monthly | $49 + per-item fees* | $29.99 + 1.7–1.9% per item* |
| Entry tier price | $9.99/mo | $49/mo | $29.99/mo |
| Per-item transaction fee | $0 (none) | Tiered (varies) | 1.7–1.9%, $0.02 floor / $15 cap |
| Free plan (no expiry) | ✓ | Trial only | Trial only |
| 2D canvas live preview | ✓ | ✓ | ✓ |
| 3D product preview | — | — | ✓ |
| AR ("try it on") preview | — | — | ✓ |
| Custom fonts | 35+ Google Fonts | Large library | 35+ (font upload top tier) |
| Logo / image upload | ✓ (Pro+) | ✓ | ✓ |
| Photo upload with crop | ✓ | ✓ (POD-optimized) | ✓ |
| Conditional logic | ✓ Single-level | ✓ Multi-level | Within 3D configs |
| Multi-step flows | ✓ | ✓ | ✓ |
| Custom option fields | 10 types | Many types | Basic |
| Print-ready file output | ✓ PNG with bleed | ✓ PDF/PNG, deep POD-optimized | Varies |
| POD integrations (Printful/Printify) | Via line item properties | ✓ Native, category-leading | Limited |
| Cart Transform native pricing | ✓ Day-one | Newer accounts | Varies |
| Multi-platform (BC, WooCommerce) | Shopify only | Shopify + BC | Shopify + BC + WooCommerce |
| White-label / multi-store | — | Higher tiers | Top tier |
| Setup time (per product) | ~5 min | ~15–30 min (POD templates) | ~5 min (2D) / days (3D) |
| Best for | 2D personalization, flat-fee, free start | Deep POD workflows | 3D + AR products |
* Customily pricing per customily.com/pricing as of 2026-07-13. Zakeke fee structure per zakeke.zendesk.com — 1.7–1.9% per customized item with $0.02 floor and $15 cap. Verify current rates on each vendor's site before deciding.
Year-one cost at four store sizes
This is the comparison that decides which app you should pick if pricing is a deciding factor. The flat-fee model and the percentage-fee models diverge dramatically as your custom-product sales grow.
| Monthly custom sales | Print It My Way | Customily* | Zakeke (1.85% avg)* |
|---|---|---|---|
| $2,500 | $9.99/mo | $49+/mo | ~$76/mo |
| $5,000 | $9.99/mo | $49+/mo | ~$122/mo |
| $25,000 | $19.99/mo (Pro) | $49+ + per-item fees | ~$492/mo |
| $100,000 | $39.99/mo (Advanced) | $49+ + per-item fees | ~$1,880/mo |
* Customily entry subscription per customily.com/pricing; per-item fees vary by tier and aren't fully transparent — the totals shown reflect base subscription only. Zakeke modeled at 1.85% (midpoint of the 1.7–1.9% published range) plus $29.99 base subscription; real Zakeke fee varies by item value with $0.02 floor and $15 cap per item per zakeke.zendesk.com.
Annual gap at $25,000/month custom sales
- Print It My Way (Pro): $239.88/year
- Customily (subscription only, before per-item fees): $588+/year
- Zakeke (subscription + 1.85% fees): ~$5,900/year
Print It My Way costs about $5,660 less per year than Zakeke at this volume — assuming you don't need 3D or AR. If you do need 3D/AR, the gap is the price of that capability, and Zakeke's the only one of the three offering it.
Pairwise head-to-heads
Customily vs Zakeke
Both charge percentage or per-item fees on top of subscription, so the cost models are structurally similar. They diverge on capability:
- Customily wins: POD-specific workflows (Printful, Printify, Gelato), print-file generation depth, POD template library.
- Zakeke wins: 3D viewer + AR preview, multi-platform support (Shopify + BigCommerce + WooCommerce), font upload on top tier.
Pick Customily if you're POD-first. Pick Zakeke if 3D/AR is core to your products.
Customily vs Print It My Way
Both are 2D personalizers; the difference is fee model and POD depth:
- Customily wins: deepest POD integration, mature print-file generation, established POD template library.
- Print It My Way wins: flat fee with no per-item charges, real free plan, $9.99 entry tier vs $49, Cart Transform native pricing, faster setup.
Pick Customily if POD is your entire fulfillment model and you need deep print-file workflows. Pick Print It My Way if POD is just one channel and you don't want a fee tax on every custom sale.
Read the full PIMW vs Customily comparison.
Zakeke vs Print It My Way
The 3D capability vs flat-fee value question:
- Zakeke wins: 3D viewer + AR preview, multi-platform, top-tier font upload.
- Print It My Way wins: flat fee, real free plan, $9.99 entry vs $29.99, no transaction fee on top of subscription, faster setup.
Pick Zakeke if 3D/AR genuinely improves your conversion on configurable products. Pick Print It My Way if 2D is enough — you'll save thousands per year at scale.
Decision tree
Three questions decide which of the three is right for your store:
Q1: Do your products need 3D rotation or AR preview?
- Yes (eyewear, furniture, jewelry, footwear) → Zakeke. The 3D + AR capability is the differentiator; accept the per-item fee.
- No, 2D is enough → continue to Q2.
Q2: Is print-on-demand your primary fulfillment model?
- Yes, POD is everything (Printful/Printify-deep workflows, complex print files, large template library) → Customily. Accept the $49/mo + per-item fees for the deepest POD integration in the category.
- No, POD is one channel among several or not at all → continue to Q3.
Q3: Is the percentage-fee or high-fixed-fee model a deal-breaker?
- Yes, you want flat fees that don't scale with your growth → Print It My Way. Flat $9.99–$39.99/month, real free plan, Cart Transform pricing.
- No, you prioritize specific features over fee model → re-evaluate Q1–Q2 against your priority feature.
Best for whom?
Pick Print It My Way if:
- Your products are flat-image personalizable (apparel, drinkware, jewelry, signs, gifts, photo products)
- You want flat-fee pricing that doesn't scale with custom-product sales
- You're starting out and want a real free plan to validate the use case
- You're Shopify-only
- You want personalization + option-sets in one app
Pick Customily if:
- Print-on-demand is your primary fulfillment model with deep Printful/Printify integration needs
- You need mature, production-ready print-file generation (PDF/PNG with bleed and color profiles)
- You're running a large POD store where the $49 subscription + per-item fees are a manageable percentage of revenue
- You sell across Shopify and BigCommerce and want one personalizer for both
Pick Zakeke if:
- Your products genuinely benefit from 3D rotation or AR preview
- You sell across Shopify + BigCommerce + WooCommerce
- You sell to enterprise customers and need white-label, multi-store, multi-language
- 3D model preparation is a worthwhile investment for your products
Honest pros & cons
Print It My Way
Pros: flat fees with no per-item charges, real free plan, Cart Transform native, bundled personalizer + option sets, $9.99 entry tier, fast setup, no admin clutter.
Cons: no 3D / AR, Shopify-only, no native POD integrations (data flows via line item properties), newer app with fewer reviews than Customily or Zakeke.
Customily
Pros: deepest POD integration in the category, production-grade print-file output, mature POD template library, multi-level conditional logic, established review base.
Cons: highest entry subscription at $49/mo, per-item fees on top, no real free plan, learning curve, less relevant outside POD-heavy stores.
Zakeke
Pros: best-in-class 3D viewer and AR preview, multi-platform, mature feature set, white-label and multi-store on top tier, font upload on top tier.
Cons: 1.7–1.9% per-item fee on top of subscription (taxes growth), no real free plan, heavy 3D setup overhead, overkill for 2D-only stores.
Migration paths
No app has automatic import from another. Migration steps are similar across all three:
- Install the new app (keep the old one running on existing products).
- Recreate one personalizer end-to-end in the new app for a single test product.
- Verify the cart, checkout, order data, and (for POD stores) the print-file output match expectations.
- Migrate products in batches. Disable the old app on each batch only after the new one is verified live.
- Old-app orders retain their original line item properties — production fulfillment continues normally.
- After your last old-app-era order is fulfilled, uninstall the old app.
Time estimate: ~5 minutes per simple product, longer for POD-template-heavy products (15–30 min) or 3D-configured products (days).
Detailed migration playbooks for specific moves:
- From Customily → Customily Alternatives page
- From Zakeke → Zakeke Alternatives page
How we built this comparison
- Pricing sources: Customily pricing from customily.com/pricing (verified 2026-07-13). Zakeke fee structure from the official help center at zakeke.zendesk.com (1.7–1.9% per item, $0.02 floor, $15 cap). Print It My Way pricing from the app's Shopify App Store listing and admin.
- Feature claims: sourced from each vendor's published documentation, Shopify App Store listings, and help centers. Where pricing or features aren't publicly disclosed (e.g. Customily's exact per-item fee tiers), we say so explicitly rather than guessing.
- Cost math: Year-one and per-month calculations use entry-tier subscriptions plus the applicable percentage fee. Discounts for annual billing are not included; per-item caps (Zakeke's $15 cap) are noted where they affect totals.
- Disclosure: we make Print It My Way; we rank it first in scenarios where the data supports it. The "Pick X if..." sections above are explicit about when Customily or Zakeke is the better choice.
- Update frequency: reviewed quarterly and re-verified when any vendor publishes material pricing or feature changes. The "Last updated" stamp at the top reflects the most recent review.
- Spot-corrections: if you spot an error, email support@printitmyway.com and we'll fix it within 48 hours.
Frequently asked questions
Which app is best: Customily, Zakeke, or Print It My Way?
It depends on your products. For deep print-on-demand integration (Printful, Printify, Gelato) with mature POD workflows, Customily at $49/month plus per-item fees (customily.com/pricing) is the category leader. For products needing 3D rotation or AR preview (eyewear, furniture, footwear), Zakeke at $29.99/month plus 1.7–1.9% per item (zakeke.zendesk.com) is best-in-class. For 2D visual personalization on a flat fee with no per-item charges — apparel, mugs, jewelry, signs, gifts — Print It My Way at $9.99–$39.99/month is the value pick with a real free plan.
What does each app actually cost in year one?
At $5,000/month in custom-product sales: Print It My Way Basic costs $9.99/month flat ($119.88/year). Customily starts at $49/month plus tiered per-item fees — depending on tier, roughly $588+/year subscription alone. Zakeke costs $29.99/month plus 1.7–1.9% transaction fees ($85–$95/month at $5k volume), totaling ~$1,450/year. The flat-fee approach scales best as your custom sales grow; percentage fees compound.
Which has the best print-on-demand integration?
Customily is the established POD-specific personalizer with the deepest Printful, Printify, and Gelato integrations, including production-ready file generation with bleed and color profile handling. Zakeke has POD integrations but they're a secondary feature. Print It My Way doesn't have direct POD integrations — personalization data flows to POD apps via Shopify's standard line item properties, which Printful and Printify both read automatically. For POD-first stores, Customily is the category leader; for POD-friendly stores where data flow via standard properties is sufficient, Print It My Way is much cheaper.
Which has 3D and AR product preview?
Zakeke is the only one of the three with native 3D product preview and AR ("try it on") capability. If your products benefit from rotation (eyewear, jewelry, footwear) or in-space AR preview (furniture, large home goods), Zakeke is the right tool despite the 1.7–1.9% per-item transaction fee on top of subscription. Customily and Print It My Way are both 2D-only.
Which has the best free plan?
Print It My Way is the only one of the three with a real free plan that doesn't expire — 1 personalizer, 1 option set, 10 product assignments, indefinitely. Customily and Zakeke offer 14-day free trials only; once the trial ends, you pay.
Can I switch between these apps?
Yes. There's no automatic import between any of them, so plan to recreate your personalizers in the new app (typically 5–15 minutes per product). Personalization data on existing orders stays on the Shopify orders themselves; only future orders use the new app. The biggest migration friction is rebuilding POD-specific templates if you're moving away from Customily — those workflows are app-specific.
Which is fastest to set up?
Print It My Way is the fastest for 2D personalization — ~5 minutes from install to a live personalizer on a product. Customily takes longer because of POD template configuration (typically 15–30 minutes per product). Zakeke is fast for 2D configurations but materially slower for 3D — uploading and texturing 3D model assets takes days per non-trivial product.
Verdict
Three apps, three pricing models, three ideal stores. Zakeke for 3D/AR. Customily for POD-heavy workflows. Print It My Way for flat-fee 2D personalization with a real free plan. Pick by capability fit first, fee model second — the cost differences at scale (thousands per year) are worth the time to get this right.
Install Print It My Way — Free See the 8-app ranking